Published June 29, 2009
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello, Faia.
For positives...
You know, from the initial description it sounded like a matrix-type story. However, after reading it (which I'm glad I did), it's a lot better than that.
The story is fresh and creative. Your character is realistic, which is something I have a struggle with.
I love your descriptions. I could visualize the creature in my head clearly; emotions and feelings were portrayed very well.
As for negatives...
Like many people above me pointed out, you need to watch those tenses, making sure to keep them all the same.
Some words could be replaced with more description. Only a couple things, nothing major in that respect.
Overall a great story, definitely worth reading. On to part two.
I have to agree with the other reviews. Lots of the sentences are ordered weirdly and it is rather off putting. Apart from that though, I have to say that the actual plot is brilliant and I would like to read more.
Hi, I'm Ellie, and I'll Be You're Reviewer For Today
What? They do? How would anyone know, Considering there are not going to be an survivors to say so.I think you can lose the totally. It makes your MC seem like an obnoxious teenager.
Telling, not showing. How is this girl feeling? Why is she drowning? Is she thinking about death? Also, there are some things that I think are described a little inaccurately.
Gives the image in my head of a sort of steamboat. Try: I watch in horror as air bubbles exit my mouth and leave, heading towards the surface.
Dont use smoke...Use something like 'thin air'.
Overall on this prologue thing, I think it is pretty good, but you should stretch it out a little bit more and maybe start before she has gotten in the mess. I don't know what happened, so lets just say this girl is going for a boat ride with her boyfriend. The boat crashes, hits the rocks. You could have some real potential action there.
___________________________________________________________________
Okay, so you've been doing this whole thing in present tense, and in these two sentences, you switch to past tense. Pleas be consitent. Also, is the main character Christian? If she knew that she was dead, wouldn't she think she was in heaven?
A little pointless description. You can take out the second paragraph which i quoted.
Here there is alot adverb and adjective repetition and things don't make sense. Instead of 'making the white ceiling begin to to fade' how about 'everything around me starts blurry. Also, Pain 'shot', you are using past tense again. With the last two sentences, telling, not showing. Describe the memories. You can delete the last sentence, because it contradicts the one before it.
I think Its been established that the woman is emotionless, and that your MC can't exactly feel anything. Also, this sentence is in past-tense again. Please pick a tense and stay with it.
Is the emotionless woman a robot?
Again, a lot of pointless description...
...
This switching between past and present tense is really starting to annoy me.
Okay, this a little bit of an adjective bomb / purple prose. It goes into over-extravagant description and stops the story.
This is good. Lots of good dialogue and description.
Again, don't stop passages of your story for over-extravagant description.
Okay, this passage is kind of boring, and a little bit of an info-dump. If she is waking up in 'The Real World', wouldn't the creature already knew she was?
Positives
This is very provocative, and has alot of good dialogue. Keeps me reading, and I can't wait to see what happens next.
Negatives
The consistency with your tenses is bad, there is some purple prose, info dumps/adjective bombs. I can't tell where the plot is going.
Overall
Great, well-thought out story. Good Idea. Can't wait to read more!"
Okay, great! I’m very, very interested so far and it sounds like you’ve got a really fresh, unique idea! This is only your second try at writing? Wow! I’m impressed!!
I love your descriptions, you keep them detailed enough to keep us paying attention and engrossed, but not too much so that we end up getting bored or skipping parts of your story. Great job! You have a lovely style.
‘Kay, right off the bat you seem to have some tense problems. Like in the prologue, Jackie goes from ‘all I can see…’, like she’s seeing it right now to ‘was stealing my life’ like she’s telling the story to someone like it happened a little while ago. This happens a lot throughout the story, and I think it’s probably your biggest problem (and it’s fixable, that’s great!). At the beginning it’s all in present tense, but at the end, somehow it switched to past tense. But I think you might know you did that.
Is tense what you’re talking about? That’s good, if you recognized what you were doing wrong.Here are some little problem things here and there that I noticed:
In my personal opinion, this sounds a bit like she be suggesting that she has short brown hair and short brown ears.
-Roo
Hello Faia. Love the story, it's increadibly creative. "My head began to spin, my stomach churn again and my heart try to break my ribcage." Part of that sentence doesn't really make sense as it is(the stomach part) it needs some other words in there. Also if you write she feels alive yet at the same time is struggling to feel something, us slow kids might get confused. Chop chop Faia, I want to see those eight reviews you owe the world.
I'm just going to annotate where I have any additional comments. I really enjoyed it btw! I think it's good for your second try at writing.
Hi Faia! I'm here to review your work.

The story itself and the plot is very good. you express your characters emotions really well which iss one thing i sometimes have problems with. However, some of your sentences are ordered weirdly and don't make sense. i know it's boring and dull but if you read through it out loud, it's really easy to spot your mistakes. please do read it over because your story is really goo d and had me hooked but the little mistakes drew my attention away from the plot. all in all your story is excellent and has potential. please PM me when you post more as i would like to read it.
Afeefah